1) Disruptive Demographics:
Implications for the Accounting Profession
James H. Johnson, Jr.
Distinguished Professor of Entrepreneurship & Strategy,
University of North Carolina─Kenan-Flagler Business School
2) Disruptive Demographics: Implications
for the Accounting Profession
James H. Johnson, Jr. , Ph.D.
Frank Hawkins Kenan Institute of Private Enterprise
Kenan-Flagler Business School
University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
October 2015
3) OVERVIEW
• Demographic Trends
• Challenges & Opportunities
• Discussion
3
4) what
CENSUS 2010
will REVEAL
October 2015
4
5)
6) 6 DISRUPTIVE TRENDS
•
•
•
•
•
•
The South Rises – Again
The Browning of America
Marrying Out is “In”
The Silver Tsunami is About Hit
The End of Men?
Cooling Water from Grandma’s Well… and Grandpa’s
Too!
6
7) The South
Continues To Rise
...Again!
7
8) South’s Share of U.S. Net Population Growth,
Selected Years, 1910-2010
Years
1910-1930
1930-1950
1950-1970
1970-1990
1990-2010
U.S.
Absolute
Population
Change
30,974,129
28,123,138
51,886,128
45,497,947
60,035,665
South’s
Absolute
Population
Change
8,468,303
9,339,455
15,598,279
22,650,563
29,104,814
South’s
Share of
Change
27%
33%
30%
50%
49%
9) U.S. POPULATION CHANGE BY REGION,
2000-2010
2010
Population
Absolute
Population
Change,
2000-2010
Percent
Population
Change,
2000-2010
309,050,816
26,884,972
9.5%
Northeast
55,417,311
1,753,978
3.3%
Midwest
66,972,887
2,480,998
3.0%
South
114,555,744
14,318,924
14.3%
West
72,256,183
8,774,852
13.8%
Region
U.S.
10) SHARES OF NET POPULATION GROWTH
BY REGION, 2000-2010
Absolute Population
Change
Percent of Total
UNITED STATES
26,884,972
100.0
NORTHEAST
1,753,978
6.0
MIDWEST
2,480,998
9.0
SOUTH
14,318,924
53.0
WEST
8,774,852
32.0
Region
11) NET MIGRATION TRENDS,
2000-2008
Northeast
Midwest
South
West
Total
-1,032
-2,008
+2,287
+46
Black
-346
-71
+376
+41
Hispanic
-292
-109
+520
-117
Elderly
-115
+42
+97
-27
Foreign
born
-147
-3
+145
+3
= Net Import
= Net Export
11
12) GROSS AND NET MIGRATION FOR THE
SOUTH, 2004-2010
The Region
Domestic
Years
In
Out
Foreign
Net
In
Out
Net
2004-2007 4,125,096 3,470,431 654,665
268,619 132,382 136,237
2007-2010 3,874,414 3,477,899 396,525
232,501 132,201 100,300
Florida
Domestic
Years
In
Out
Foreign
Net
In
Out
Net
2004-2007
812,053
630,051 182,002
41,745
24,108
17,637
2007-2010
654,931
668,087
33,095
32,094
1,001
-13,156
13) State Share of South’s Net Growth,
2000-2010
Region/State
The South
Texas
Florida
Georgia
North Carolina
Other Southern
States
Absolute Change State’s Share
14,318,924
100.0%
4,293,741
30.0%
2,818,932
19.7%
1,501,200
10.5%
1,486,170
10.4%
4,218,881
29.4%
13
14) U.S. POPULATION CHANGE BY REGION,
2010-2014
2014
Population
Absolute
Population
Change,
2010-2014
Percent
Population
Change,
2010-2014
318,857,056
10,098,951
3.3%
Northeast
56,152,333
833,985
1.5%
Midwest
67,745,108
815,210
1.2%
South
119,771,934
5,208,983
4.5%
West
75,187,681
3,240,773
4.5%
Region
U.S.
15) SHARES OF NET POPULATION GROWTH
BY REGION, 2010-2014
Absolute Population
Change
Percent of Total
10,098,951
100.0
NORTHEAST
833,985
8.3
MIDWEST
815,210
8.1
SOUTH
5,208,983
51.6
WEST
3,240,773
32.1
Region
UNITED STATES
16) STATE SHARES OF SOUTH’S NET
GROWTH, 2010-2014
Region/State
Absolute Change
State’s Share
The South
5,208,983
100.0%
Texas
1,810,854
34.8%
Florida
1,088,674
20.9%
Georgia
408,662
7.8%
North Carolina
408,273
7.8%
Virginia
325,265
6.2%
1,167,255
22.4%
Other Southern States
17) THE “BROWNING”
OF AMERICA
17
18)
19) The Numbers
Legal Immigrants
Year
1920-1961
1961-1992
1993-1998
1999-2004
2005-2008
2009-2012
Refugees, Parolees, Asylees
Annual
Flow
206,000
561,000
800,654
879,400
1,137,000
1,067,000
Year
1961-1993
Annual
Flow
65,000
1994-1998 107,000
1999-2004
85,500
2005-2008
75,000
2009-2012
92,500
20) The Numbers Cont’d
• Illegal Immigrants
300,000 to 400,000 annually over the past two decades
Three million granted amnesty in 1986
2.7 million illegal immigrants remained after 1986 reforms
October 1996: INS estimated there were 5 million illegal
immigrants in U.S.
• Since August 2005: Estimates of illegal population have
ranged between 7 million and 15 million
• Today: An estimated 11.5 million unauthorized immigrants
reside in U.S.
•
•
•
•
21) NON-IMMIGRANTS ADMITTED TO UNITED STATES,
SELECTED YEARS, 1981-2011
Year
All Classes
Exchange Visitors Academic &
Vocational
Students
1981
11,756,903
108,023 (1%)
271,861 (2%)
1985
9,539,880
141,213 (1%)
285,496 (3%)
1990
17,574,055
214,644 (1%)
355,207 (2%)
1995
22,640,540
241,364 (1%)
395,480 (2%)
2000
33,690,082
351,743 (1%)
699,953 (2%)
2001
32,824,088
389,435 (1%)
741,921 (2%)
2002
27,907,139
370,176 (1%)
687,506 (2%)
2008
39,381,928
506,138 (1%)
917,373 (2%)
2011
53,082,286
526, 931 (1%)
1,702,730 (3%)
22)
23) Number of Immigrants (in millions)
U.S. Immigrant Population,
1900-2011
45
40.4
40
35.2
35
31.1
30
25
19.8
20
15
10
10.3
13.5 13.9
14.2
11.6
14.1
10.3
9.7
9.6
5
0
1900 1910 1920 1930 1940 1950 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2005 2011
Year
24) U.S. Foreign Born Population by
Race/Ethnicity, 2011
Race/Ethnicity
Foreign Population
Share of Total (%)
Total
40,381,574
100.0
Hispanic
18,788,300
46.5
White Alone, not
Hispanic
7,608,236
18.8
Black Alone, not
Hispanic
3,130,348
7.8
Asian Alone, not
Hispanic
9,988,159
24.7
Other Alone, not
Hispanic
866,531
2.1
24
25) U.S. POPULATION CHANGE BY RACE &
ETHNICITY, 2000-2010
Absolute Change
2000 – 2010
Percentage
Change
2000 - 2010
Race
2010 Population
Total
308,745,538
27,323,632
9.7%
258,267,944
12,151,856
4.9%
196,817,552
2,264,778
1.2%
37,685,848
3,738,011
11.0%
2,247,098
178,215
8.6%
14,465,124
4,341,955
42.9%
128,067
36.2%
5,966,481
1,364,335
29.6%
50,477,594
15,171,776
43.0%
Non-Hispanic
White
Black
AI/AN
Asian
NH/PI
2 or More Races
Hispanic
481,576
26) NON-WHITE AND HISPANIC SHARES OF
POPULATION GROWTH, 2000-2010
Area
Absolute
Population
Change
Non-White
Share
Hispanic
Share
US
27,323,632
91.7
55.5
South
14,318,924
79.6
46.4
Texas
4,293,741
89.2
65.0
Florida
2,818,932
84.9
54.7
Georgia
1,501,206
81.0
27.9
NC
1,486,170
61.2
28.3
27) MEDIAN AGE OF U.S. POPULATION BY
RACE, HISPANIC ORIGIN & GENDER, 2009
Race
Total
Male
Female
United States
36.8
35.4
38.2
White Alone
38.3
37.0
39.6
White, Non-Hispanic
41.2
39.9
42.6
Black Alone
31.3
29.4
33.3
AI/AN Alone
29.5
29.0
30.2
Asian Alone
33.6
32.6
34.6
NH/PI Alone
29.9
29.5
30.3
Two or More Races
19.7
18.9
20.5
Hispanic
27.4
27.4
27.5
27
28) TOTAL FERTILITY RATES FOR U.S.
WOMEN BY RACE/ETHNICITY, 2012
Race/Ethnicity
Total Fertility Rate
All Races
1.88
Hispanic
2.18
Non-Hispanic White
1.76
Blacks
1.90
Asian
1.77
Native American
1.35
29) RELATIVE DISTRIBUTION OF U.S.
BIRTHS BY RACE / ETHNICITY
Race/Ethnicity
1990
2008
2011
White
66%
50%
49.6%
Blacks
17%
16%
15.0%
Hispanics
15%
26%
26.0%
2%
8%
9.4%
Other
Source: Johnson and Lichter (2010); Tavernise (2011).
30) RELATIVE DISTRIBUTION OF U.S.
POPULATION BY RACE / ETHNICITY
Race/Ethnicity
White
Blacks
Hispanics
Asian
2005
2050
67%
47%
12.8%
13%
14%
29%
5%
9%
Source: Pew Research Center, 2008 *projected.
30
31) Marrying Out
September 2014
is “In”
31
32) INTERMARRIAGE TREND, 1980-2008
% Married Someone of a Different Race/Ethnicity
32
33) EDUCATION & INTERMARRIAGE
% of Newlyweds Who Married Someone
of a Different Race/Ethnicity, 2008
33
34) INTERMARRIAGE TYPES
Newly Married Couples in 2008
34
35) INTERMARRIAGE RATES BY
RACE & ETHNICITY
% of Newlyweds Who Married Someone of a Different Race/Ethnicity, 2008
35
36) THE SILVER TSUNAMI
36
37) U.S. POPULATION CHANGE BY AGE,
2000-2009
Age
<25
2009
Absolute
Change
2000 - 2009
Percentage
Change
2000 - 2009
104,960,250
5,258,492
5.3
25-44
84,096,278
-1,898,345
-2.2
45-64
79,379,439
16,977,567
27.2
65+
39,570,590
4,496,886
12.8
307,006,550
24,834,593
8.8
TOTAL
37
38) U.S. POPULATION TURNING 50, 55, 62,
AND 65 YEARS OF AGE, (2007-2015)
Age
50
Average Number/Day
Average Number/Minute
Age
55
Age
62
Age
65
12,344
11,541
9,221
8,032
8.6
8.0
6.4
5.6
38
39) THE GREYING OF AMERICA
U.S. Census Projections
39
40) ABSOLUTE AND PERCENT CHANGE
IN U.S. POPULATION BY AGE
Age
2005
2050
% Change
Total
296
438
50.0
0-17
73
102
39.7
18-64
186
255
37.1
37
81
118.9
65+
40
41) OLDER WORKERS IN U.S. WORKFORCE
YEAR
Age 65 or
Older
Age 75 or
Older
1998
11.9%
4.7%
2008
16.8%
7.3%
September 2014
41
42) DEPENDENCY RATIOS IN THE AMERICAN
SOUTH
Source: Census 2010
43) The End of Men?
43
44) FEMALE WORKFORCE REPRESENTATION
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
1970
1980
1990
% Female
2000
2010
44
45) The Plight of Men
• Today, three times as many men of working age do not work at all compared to
1969.
• Selective male withdrawal from labor market—rising non-employment due largely
to skills mismatches, disabilities & incarceration.
• The percentage of prime-aged men receiving disability insurance doubled
between 1970 (2.4%) and 2009 (4.8%).
• Since 1969 median wage of the American male has declined by almost $13,000
after accounting for inflation.
• After peaking in 1977, male college completion rates have barely changed over the
past 35 years.
46) COLLEGE CLASS OF 2010
DEGREE
MALE
FEMALE
DIFFERENCE
Associate’s
293,000
486,000
193,000
Bachelor’s
702,000
946,000
244,000
Master’s
257,000
391,000
134,000
Professional
46,800
46,400
-400
Doctor’s
31,500
32,900
1,400
1,330,300
1,902,300
572,000
TOTAL
46
47) September 2014
47
48) Jobs Lost/Gained by Gender During
2007 (Q4) – 2009 (Q3) Recession
Industry
Women
Construction
-106,000
Manufacturing -106,000
Healthcare
+451,800
Government
+176,000
Total
-1,700,000
Men
-1,300,000
-1,900,000
+118,100
+12,000
-4,700,000
48
49) Cooling Waters From
Grandma’s Well
And Grandpa’s Too!
September 2014
49
50) Children Living in Non-Grandparent and Grandparent Households,
2001-2010
Household Type
Absolute Number Absolute Change
2010
2001-2010
All
74,718
2,712
3.8
No Grandparents 67,209
917
1.4
Both
Grandparents
2,610
771
41.9
Grandmother
Only
1,922
164
9.3
318
71
28.7
Grandfather Only
Percent Change
2001-2010
50
51) Children Living in Non-Grandparent and Grandparent-Headed
Households by Presence of Parents, 2010
Household
Type
All Children
Living with
(in thousands) Both
Parents
Living with
Mother
Only
Living with
Father
Only
Living with
Neither
parent
All
74,718
69.3%
23.1%
3.4%
4.0%
No
Grandparents
67,209
73.4%
21.2%
3.3%
2.1%
Both
Grandparents
2,610
18.1%
40.6%
5.2%
36.1%
Grandmother
Only
1,922
13.8%
48.4%
4.5%
33.2%
Grandfather
Only
318
26.4%
45.9%
4.4%
23.6%
51
52) DIVERSITY RULES
...but Challenges Abound
52
53) The Triple Whammy of Geographical
Disadvantage
The Human Capital Challenge
54)
55)
56)
57)
58) Education is Necessary
...but insufficient
58
59) AVERAGE SHARE OF LONG-TERM
UNEMPLOYMENT BY EDUCATION
Education
1990-1993
2001-2004
% Change
Less Than High School
23.7%
-1.0
High School Graduate
40.6%
34.3%
-6.3
Some College
20.7%
24.4%
3.7
Bachelor’s Degree
or More
September 2014
24.7%
14.0%
17.6%
3.6
59
60) AVERAGE SHARE OF LONG-TERM
UNEMPLOYMENT BY OCCUPATION
Occupation
1990-1993
2001-2004
% Change
Blue Collar
40.5%
31.6%
-8.9
Service Occupation
14.3%
16.7%
2.4
White Collar
38.5%
44.4%
5.9
60
61) THE LONG-TERM UNEMPLOYED, 2009
PROFESSION
% OF ALL
JOBLESS WORKERS
Architecture & Engineering
41.2
Management
39.0
Community & Social Services Occupations
36.1
Installation, Maintenance & Repair Work
34.9
Production Occupations
33.4
61
62) THE COMPETITIVE TOOL KIT
• Analytical Reasoning
• Entrepreneurial Acumen
• Contextual Intelligence
• Soft Skills/Cultural Elasticity
• Agility and Flexibility
63) Implications for Workforce Planning and
Development
• Managing transition from the “graying” to the
“browning” of America.
• Competition for talent will be fierce – and global.
• Successful recruitment and retention will hinge on your
ability to effectively manage the full nexus of “diversity”
issues.
63
64) Diversity Challenges and Opportunities in the
Accounting Profession
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Workforce Changing Rapidly
Lucrative Ethnic Markets for Services
Glass/Bamboo Ceiling
Promotion and Retention of Women & Minorities
High Turnover
Sexual Harassment
Succession Planning
64
65) Iceberg Model of Diversity
Visible Diversity Traits
If all I
know
about you
is what I
can see…
Race/Skin Color
Gender
Visible Disability
Age Group
Physical Attributes
Ethnicity
Invisible Diversity Traits
Level in Organization Culture Marital Status
Values Education
MBTI
Religion/Religious Experiences
International Cultural Immersion
Communication Style Conflict Style Beliefs Teaching Style
Recreational Habits
IQ Learning Styles
Academic Discipline Literacy
Sexual Orientation
Personality Style
Orientation to Time Family Relationships Orientation to Tasks
Physical Abilities/Qualities
EQ Military Experience
Socioeconomic Status
Geographic Background
Work Background
Smoker/Non-Smoker
Parental Status Native Born/Non-Native Born Political Ideology
Thinking Style
66) THE END