1) Uniform CPA Examination:
Past, Present & Future
June 2015
Colleen Conrad, CPA – Executive Vice President/COO, NASBA
Michael Decker – Vice President, Examinations, AICPA
Rick Niswander, CPA – Chair, AICPA Board of Examiners
2) Our Mission
Exam’s role in
protecting
the public
interest
Why?
Provide reasonable assurance to
boards of accountancy that candidates
who pass the CPA Exam possess the
level of technical knowledge and the
skills necessary for initial licensure to
protect the public interest.
American Institute of CPAs®
The Uniform CPA Examination®
2
3) Why a Practice Analysis?
What do we test?
Ensures relevancy with
and
the profession
How do we test it?
American Institute of CPAs®
The Uniform CPA Examination®
3
4) Exam Evolution
2004
Paper
&
Pencil
Conversion
•â€¯ Release of CBT-e in 2011
•â€¯ Shorter score release timelines
•â€¯ Writing in BEC only
•â€¯ Four pillars assumed
•â€¯ No changes to test administration
2008
CBT-­â€e
•â€¯ Led to the computerization of the
Exam in 2004
•â€¯ Creation of the original CBT
testing policies and procedures
American Institute of CPAs®
Next
Version
•â€¯ Assumed nothing
•â€¯ Anticipated
changes from 10
years of CBT
experience
The Uniform CPA Examination®
4
5) Research Project Timeline
Full implementation of the new Test Driver, with Excel, in 2018
American Institute of CPAs®
The Uniform CPA Examination®
5
6) What We Learned
Critical thinking,
problem solving,
analytical ability
and professional
skepticism
Effective
communication
skills
American Institute of CPAs®
Content knowledge is
the key to protecting
the public interest –
but alone it is not
enough
Well-developed
research skills
A strong
understanding of
the business
environment and
processes
Ethics and
professional
responsibilities
The Uniform CPA Examination®
6
7) ITC Results: Key Feedback
Support
•â€¯ Current Exam structure
•â€¯ Assessment of practice-driven
concepts via writing
Other Comments
•â€¯ Extend testing in blackout
periods
•â€¯ Allow retesting within window
•â€¯ Assessment of higher-order
skills via integration
•â€¯ Exam enhancements with
reasonable price and score
reporting impact
•â€¯ Microsoft Excel as a tool
American Institute of CPAs®
The Uniform CPA Examination
7
8) Next Version of the
CPA Examination
American Institute of CPAs®
9) Exam
Blueprint & Structure
American Institute of CPAs®
10) Content Assessment
" Pillars of AUD, FAR, REG and BEC
" Enhance blueprints with depth and breadth across
topic areas – content & skill level
•â€¯ Note that this is significant enhancement to the Exam!
" Increased assessment of higher-order skills
warrants increased use of task-based simulations
" Skill / content allocation will change based upon
blueprint and survey results
American Institute of CPAs®
The Uniform CPA Examination®
10
11) Leveling of Skills
Remember &
Understand
Application
Analysis
Evaluation
American Institute of CPAs®
The perception and comprehension of the
significance of an area utilizing knowledge
gained.
The use or demonstration of knowledge,
concepts or techniques.
The examination and study of the
interrelationships of separate areas in order to
identify causes and find evidence to support
inferences.
The examination or assessment of problems,
and use of judgment to draw conclusions.
The Uniform CPA Examination®
11
12) Sample of Action Verbs for Consideration
Remember &
Understand
Application
Analysis
Evaluation
American Institute of CPAs®
Identify
Classify
Recall
Explain
Categorize
Clarify
Compare
Define
Calculate
Implement
Test
Represent
Prepare
Use
Execute
Carry out
Reconcile
Deconstruct
Validate
Deduce
Imply
Integrate
Distinguish
Organize
Justify
Critique
Conclude
Judge
Detect
Verify
Recommend
Assess
The Uniform CPA Examination®
12
13) FAR Section: DRAFT Blueprint Example
Remembering Application Analysis Evaluation Total
Area I: Conceptual
Frameworks and
Financial Reporting
(25%)
Area II: Select
Financial Statement
Accounts (35%)
14%
43%
44%
0%
100%
7%
49%
45%
0%
100%
Area III: Select
Transactions (30%)
Area IV: State and
Local Governments
(10%)
18%
60%
22%
0%
100%
41%
57%
1%
0%
100%
Skill Allocation
Percentage
15%
52%
33%
0%
100%
American Institute of CPAs®
The Uniform CPA Examination®
13
14) FAR Area 1 – Current CSO / SSO View
Next Exam Blueprint
American Institute of CPAs®
The Uniform CPA Examination
14
15) DRAFT - Section Skill Allocation
Area
Remember
&
Understand
ApplicaAon
Analysis
EvaluaAon
AUD
30%
-­â€
40%
30%
-­â€
40%
15%
-­â€
25%
5%
-­â€10%
FAR
10%
-­â€
20%
50%
-­â€
60%
25%
-­â€
35%
-­â€
REG
25%
-­â€
35%
35%
-­â€
45%
25%
-­â€
35%
-­â€
BEC
15%
-­â€
25%
50%
-­â€
60%*
20%
-­â€
30%
-­â€
*10% - 20% will be Written Communication
American Institute of CPAs®
The Uniform CPA Examination®
15
16) Examples of Higher-Order Tasks
" Evaluate evidence through the use of observation
and inspection procedures in an audit or non-audit
engagement.
" Verify the ending inventory balance by observing
the performance of inventory counting procedures,
inspecting the inventory, and performing test
counts.
" Investigate debt covenant violations and determine
their impact on the financial statements and the
notes to the financial statements.
American Institute of CPAs®
The Uniform CPA Examination®
16
17) Assessing Written Content
" BOE support: Continue to test separately
•â€¯ Writing / grammar
•â€¯ Content knowledge
•â€¯ Higher-order skills (application, analysis, evaluation/conclusion)
" Writing will continue to be tested and scored using
current model that considers whether the written
communication is (i) on topic (ii) organized and (iii)
grammatically correct
" Continue research on automated scoring of essays
American Institute of CPAs®
The Uniform CPA Examination®
17
18) Exam Design
American Institute of CPAs®
19) Exam Time – pending final blueprints
Section
Current Time
Proposed Time*
AUD
4 hours
[4 hours]
FAR
4 hours
[4 hours]
REG
3 hours
[4 hours]
BEC
3 hours
[4 hours]
4 sections
14 hours
[16 hours]
*16 hours is subject to change as we finalize section blueprints and the Exposure Draft
American Institute of CPAs®
The Uniform CPA Examination®
19
20) Excel Implementation
" Implement Excel as a tool for candidates in 2018
•â€¯ Replaces generic spreadsheet
•â€¯ Candidates may use basic or advanced Excel skills to complete
a problem
" Excel skills will not be directly assessed
" Continue internal research on:
•â€¯ Excel spreadsheets embedded in an item
•â€¯ Excel spreadsheets as an item
American Institute of CPAs®
The Uniform CPA Examination®
20
21) Test Administration
American Institute of CPAs®
22) Test Administration Model* (potential changes)
" Extend testing to the 10th of the black-out month
•â€¯
•â€¯
•â€¯
•â€¯
Allow up to 5 days of emergency window** if possible
Adds 40 – 60 days of testing annually
Windows do not end near major holidays (Thanksgiving, etc.)
Allows testing in March, June, September and December
" Allow re-testing of a failed section within a window
•â€¯ Create policy that candidate cannot register for re-test until he/
she has received score
•â€¯ Candidates may only take the same section 2x per window
* Changes require review and approval by NASBA, AICPA, Prometric, and Boards of
Accountancy
** Emergency window use requires approval by NASBA, AICPA and Prometric
American Institute of CPAs®
The Uniform CPA Examination®
22
23) Price*
" ITC response reflected understanding and
acceptance of a reasonable price increase with
appropriate added benefits
" Exam fees are likely to increase
•â€¯
•â€¯
•â€¯
•â€¯
•â€¯
•â€¯
Excel implementation
Increased item development costs
Increased software development costs
Potential additional testing / seat time
NASBA Gateway system enhancements
Flat to down candidate section volumes
* Changes require review and approval by NASBA, AICPA, Prometric, and Boards of
Accountancy
American Institute of CPAs®
The Uniform CPA Examination®
23
24) 2015 – 2017
Path to the Next CPA Exam
American Institute of CPAs®
25) Finalize in 2015-2016
Blueprints
Structure
Design
Exam
content and
skills outline
Exam
sections,
item
distributions
Exam test
scoring,
length, forms
American Institute of CPAs®
Administration
Testing
windows,
timeline for
testing
The Uniform CPA Examination®
25
26) Call to action:
Last opportunity to comment
Exposure
Draft
Contains blueprints,
structure, design
and administration
of Next CPA Exam
Public Comment
September –
November 2015
American Institute of CPAs®
The Uniform CPA Examination®
26
27) Exposure Draft: What Do You Think?
Is the next version of the Exam on the
right track? Was anything missed?
What are your thoughts for continual
improvement of the Exam post Q2 2017?
American Institute of CPAs®
The Uniform CPA Examination®
27
28) American Institute of CPAs®
The Uniform CPA Examination®
28
29) Questions?
American Institute of CPAs®
The Uniform CPA Examination®
29